Fairhope's Neighborhood Pizzeria

A Slice That Feels Like Coming Home

Hand-tossed dough, garden-fresh toppings, and recipes passed down through generations — every pie is made the way it should be, right here in Fairhope.

(251) 990-7757 Explore the Menu
Scroll
Pizza chef tossing dough by hand in a warm brick oven

Our Story

Three Decades of Real Pizza, Right Here in Fairhope

Papa's Pizza started with a simple conviction: the best pizza doesn't need a fancy menu — it needs fresh ingredients, a well-seasoned crust, and someone who actually cares about every pie that leaves the oven.

For over twenty years, we've been serving our neighbors on the Fairhope Peninsula with pies baked to order, salads tossed that morning, and a dining room that feels like a second living room. No rush. No pretense. Just good food and the kind of hospitality that makes you want to come back.

Hand-Tossed Daily
Fresh Ingredients
Family Owned

The Papa's Difference

What Makes Us Different

It's not just what goes on the pizza — it's how we treat you from the moment you walk in.

Made with Care

Every dough ball is hand-stretched. Every pie is watched. We don't rush the oven, and we don't cut corners.

Quality You Can Taste

Premium flour, real mozzarella, imported sauces, and toppings that arrive fresh — because shortcuts never tasted this good.

A Neighborhood Spot

We know our regulars by name. Families, friends, and folks just passing through — everyone finds a seat at our table.

Order & Pick Up

Call ahead and we'll have your pie ready — hot, fresh, and waiting when you pull into the parking lot on Greeno Road.

What Our Guests Say

Loved by Our Neighbors

The best compliment we get comes from folks who've been eating here for years — and bringing their families back ever since.

“

We've been coming to Papa's for family dinners for over ten years. The pizza never changes — in the best possible way. It's always reliable, always hot, and always feels like home.

A Fairhope Family

Fairhope, AL

“

The crust is unlike anything I've had at other places in the area. You can tell it's made fresh every day. And the staff treats you like you've known them forever.

A Regular Visitor

Daphne, AL

“

Called ahead on a busy Friday and my pizza was ready in minutes. Perfectly crispy, loaded with toppings, and still warm when I got it home. That's the kind of spot this is.

A Satisfied Customer

Biloxi, MS

Find Us

Come Eat with Us

We're right here on Greeno Road, ready to serve you pie after pie.

Address

333 Greeno Rd S

Fairhope, AL 36532

Call to Order

(251) 990-7757

Order ahead for pickup — we'll have it ready when you arrive.

Hours

Open Seven Days

Monday – Friday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Saturday – Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Call Now to Order
Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website